Question
Download Solution PDFDespite having the highest possible efficiency for Carnot cycle, it is not suitable for a practical engine using a gaseous working fluid as:
Answer (Detailed Solution Below)
Detailed Solution
Download Solution PDFExplanation:
The Carnot cycle is a theoretical thermodynamic cycle proposed by Nicolas Léonard Sadi Carnot in 1824. It is considered the most efficient cycle possible for converting heat into work, or extracting work from heat. The efficiency of the Carnot cycle is given by the difference in temperature between the heat source and the heat sink, divided by the temperature of the heat source. Despite its theoretical efficiency, the Carnot cycle is not suitable for practical engines using gaseous working fluids for several reasons.
The correct answer is option 3: it is impossible to achieve perfectly reversible processes. Let's delve into the detailed explanation of why this is the case:
Correct Option Analysis:
Impossibility of Perfectly Reversible Processes:
The Carnot cycle consists of two isothermal processes (one at a high temperature and one at a low temperature) and two adiabatic processes. To achieve the highest efficiency, each of these processes must be perfectly reversible. A reversible process is an idealization and assumes no entropy generation, no friction, no unrestrained expansion, and no heat transfer through a finite temperature difference. In reality, these conditions are impossible to meet:
- Friction: All practical engines experience some form of friction, whether it is in the pistons, the bearings, or other moving parts. This friction generates entropy and makes the process irreversible.
- Heat Transfer: In the Carnot cycle, heat must be transferred isothermally, which requires an infinitely slow process to ensure that the system remains in thermal equilibrium with the heat reservoirs. In practice, heat transfer occurs over a finite temperature difference, which makes the process irreversible.
- Unrestrained Expansion: In real engines, there are always losses associated with unrestrained expansion or compression of gases. This leads to entropy generation and irreversibility.
- Entropy Generation: Any practical process will generate entropy due to various irreversibilities, including friction, rapid expansion or compression, and heat transfer through finite temperature differences. This makes it impossible to achieve the idealized reversible processes assumed in the Carnot cycle.
Due to these inherent practical limitations, it is impossible to achieve the perfectly reversible processes required for the Carnot cycle. As a result, while the Carnot cycle provides a useful benchmark for the maximum possible efficiency, it cannot be realized in a practical engine using a gaseous working fluid.
Analysis of Other Options:
Option 1: The cycle requires very high pressures that are hard to manage:
While high pressures can pose challenges in managing and maintaining engines, it is not the primary reason why the Carnot cycle is not suitable for practical engines. The main issue lies in the impossibility of achieving perfectly reversible processes, not the pressures involved.
Option 2: It is easy to maintain isothermal processes in practice:
This statement is incorrect. In fact, it is quite difficult to maintain isothermal processes in practice, especially in a dynamic system like an engine. Isothermal processes require very slow heat transfer to ensure thermal equilibrium, which is not feasible in practical applications.
Option 4: The work output from the cycle is quite low:
While the work output of any cycle depends on the specific conditions and design, the Carnot cycle is theoretically the most efficient cycle. Therefore, the work output should not be inherently low. The main issue is achieving the theoretical efficiency in practice.
In conclusion, the primary reason the Carnot cycle is not suitable for practical engines using a gaseous working fluid is the impossibility of achieving perfectly reversible processes. This inherent limitation makes it impossible to realize the theoretical efficiency of the Carnot cycle in real-world applications.
Last updated on Jun 7, 2025
-> RRB JE CBT 2 answer key 2025 for June 4 exam has been released at the official website.
-> Check Your Marks via RRB JE CBT 2 Rank Calculator 2025
-> RRB JE CBT 2 admit card 2025 has been released.
-> RRB JE CBT 2 city intimation slip 2025 for June 4 exam has been released at the official website.
-> RRB JE CBT 2 Cancelled Shift Exam 2025 will be conducted on June 4, 2025 in offline mode.
-> RRB JE CBT 2 Exam Analysis 2025 is Out, Candidates analysis their exam according to Shift 1 and 2 Questions and Answers.
-> The RRB JE Notification 2024 was released for 7951 vacancies for various posts of Junior Engineer, Depot Material Superintendent, Chemical & Metallurgical Assistant, Chemical Supervisor (Research) and Metallurgical Supervisor (Research).
-> The selection process includes CBT 1, CBT 2, and Document Verification & Medical Test.
-> The candidates who will be selected will get an approximate salary range between Rs. 13,500 to Rs. 38,425.
-> Attempt RRB JE Free Current Affairs Mock Test here
-> Enhance your preparation with the RRB JE Previous Year Papers.