Quick Links

Home / IAS Preparation / Discuss the merits & demerits of the four Labour Codes in India

Discuss the merits & demerits of the four Labour Codes in India

Last Updated on Sep 27, 2024

Also Read Discuss the merits & demerits of the four Labour Codes in India in Hindi

IMPORTANT LINKS

Agriculture Notes For UPSC Public Administration UPSC Notes Modern History Books For UPSC Overseas Citizen Of India Caste System & Panchayati Raj Godavari River Federalism Indira Point New Development Bank Battle Of Sinhagad Sankalp And Strive Schemes Digital India High Yielding Varieties Economic Growth Development League Of Nations Ease Of Doing Business Mid Day Meal Scheme Wildlife Protection Act 1972 UPSC Notes International Union Conservation Nature

Discuss the merits and demerits of the four Labour Codes’ in the context of labour market reforms in India. What has been the progress so far in this regard?
This topic analyzes the advantages and disadvantages of the four new Labor Codes in India, assessing their impact on labor market reforms and the progress made in their implementation. It belongs to General Studies Paper III: Technology, Economic Development, Bio-diversity, Environment, Security and Disaster Management.

Approach:

Introduction: Define the four labor codes and their significance in the context of labor market reforms.

Body: Discuss merits (simplification, flexibility, social security) and demerits (implementation challenges, criticism on worker rights) of each labor code. Highlight progress made so far.

Conclusion: Summarize with a way forward, emphasizing the need for balanced reforms ensuring both economic growth and worker welfare.

India's labor market reforms have been consolidated into four labor codes—the Code on Wages, the Code on Industrial Relations, the Code on Social Security, and the Code on Occupational Safety, Health, and Working Conditions. These codes aim to streamline over 29 central labor laws and improve ease of doing business while ensuring social security for workers.

FREEMentorship Program by

Ravi Kapoor, Ex-IRS

UPSC Exam-Hacker, Author, Super Mentor, MA

100+ Success Stories

Key Highlights

Achieve your Goal with our mentorship program, offering regular guidance and effective exam strategies.

Cultivate a focused mindset for exam success through our mentorship program.

UPSC Beginners Program

Get UPSC Beginners Program SuperCoaching @ just

₹50000

Claim for free

Merits of the Four Labor Codes

Simplification of Laws

Rationalization: Consolidating numerous labor laws into four codes simplifies the regulatory framework, reducing compliance burdens on businesses, especially MSMEs.
Ease of Compliance: It improves the ease of doing business by introducing uniform definitions, reducing litigation, and enabling digital records.

Labor Market Flexibility

Ease of Hiring and Firing: The Industrial Relations Code allows firms with up to 300 workers to lay off employees without government approval, promoting flexibility and attracting investment.
Fixed-Term Employment: The new provisions encourage hiring through fixed- term contracts, providing companies with flexibility while ensuring workers’ benefits.

Improved Social Security

Wider Coverage: The Code on Social Security expands social security benefits like provident fund, insurance, and maternity benefits to gig and platform workers.
Unorganized Sector Inclusion: Provisions ensure coverage of unorganized workers,gig workers(swiggy,zomato etc.) enhancing their access to state welfare schemes.

Better Worker Safety

Occupational Safety Focus: The Occupational Safety, Health, and Working Conditions Code ensures improved workplace safety standards, especially for hazardous industries, and mandates worker welfare measures like working hours, leaves, and health inspections.

Demerits of the Four Labor Codes

Implementation Challenges

State-Level Differences: Since labor is a concurrent subject, different states may interpret and implement codes differently, creating inconsistencies.
Lack of Infrastructure: Poor digital and institutional infrastructure may hinder the effective implementation of social security provisions for informal workers.

Criticism on Worker Rights

Lack of Protections for Informal Workers: Although the codes promise social security to informal and gig workers, implementation mechanisms remain unclear, leaving many without real protections.
Weakened Labor Unions: The Industrial Relations Code restricts the right to strike, making it harder for unions to organize and bargain collectively, raising concerns about worker exploitation.

Exclusion of Smaller Enterprises

Threshold Exemptions: Many small firms employing less than 10 workers are exempt from several provisions, potentially excluding a significant portion of the labor force from protections like minimum wage and safety standards.

Concerns Over Job Security

Increased Precarity: The ease of hiring and firing may lead to job insecurity, particularly for fixed-term contract workers, raising concerns over the erosion of permanent employment opportunities.

Progress So Far

Legislative Progress: All four codes have been passed by Parliament between 2019 and 2020. However, implementation has been delayed due to the need for further consultation with states and stakeholders.

Digital Initiatives: Steps have been taken to digitize labor-related processes, such as the E-Shram portal, which has registered millions of informal workers for social security benefits.

State Readiness: Several states have already prepared draft rules for implementation. However, uniformity in state-level execution remains a challenge.

Stakeholder Pushback: Trade unions and labor groups have voiced concerns, demanding stronger worker protections, which has slowed full-scale implementation.

Conclusion
The four labor codes are a significant step toward reforming India’s labor market, aiming for a balance between promoting business growth and ensuring worker welfare. However, for these reforms to be effective, careful implementation with stakeholder engagement, strong monitoring, and a commitment to inclusivity are essential. Going forward, addressing concerns of labor unions and improving state-level coordination will be crucial to achieving sustainable labor reforms.
Testbook offers good quality preparation material for different competitive examinations. Succeed in your UPSC IAS exam preparations by downloading the Testbook App here!

Report An Error

PSC Exams

Latest Exam Update

Coaching

UPSC Current Affairs

Syllabus

UPSC Notes

Previous Year Papers

Mock Tests

UPSC Editorial

Books

Government Schemes

Topics

Bilateral Ties