It is impossible for heat to flow from a body at a lower temperature to a body at a higher temperature without the aid of external work. This statement is

This question was previously asked in
HPCL Engineer Mechanical 12 Aug 2021 Official Paper (Shift 2)
View all HPCL Engineer Papers >
  1. Clausius statement
  2. Brayton’s statement
  3. Kirchhoff’s statement
  4. Kelvin-Planck Statement

Answer (Detailed Solution Below)

Option 1 : Clausius statement
Free
Environmental Engineering for All AE/JE Civil Exams Mock Test
10.6 K Users
20 Questions 20 Marks 20 Mins

Detailed Solution

Download Solution PDF

Explanation:

Clausius statement:

“It is impossible to construct a device that operates on a cycle to produce no effect other than the transfer of heat from a lower-temperature body to a higher temperature body”

F1 Sumit Madhu 17.08.20 D 1

The conclusion of this statement is commonly known to us that heat does not, on its own, flow from a cold medium to a hot medium. On the surface, it looks that as per Clausius statement it is impossible to construct a device that transfers heat from a colder medium to warmer medium.

The Clausius statement implies that a refrigerator will not operate unless its compressor is driven by a power source, such as an electric motor.

Additional Information

Kelvin-Planck statement:

It is impossible to construct an engine, which while operating in a cycle produces no other effect except to extract heat from a single reservoir and do the equivalent amount of work.

F1 Sumit Madhu 17.08.20 D 2

Therefore if the engine has to work in a cycle then some amount of heat is rejected in the cycle, the Closed-cycle gas turbine, internal combustion engine and steam power plant rejects some heat to produce the work continuously in a cycle, therefore these devices imply with the Kelvin-Planck statement. 

Latest HPCL Engineer Updates

Last updated on Jun 2, 2025

-> HPCL Engineer 2025 notification has been released on June 1, 2025.

-> A total of 175 vacancies have been announced for the HPCL Engineer post in Civil, Electrical, Mechanical, Chemical engineering.

-> HPCL Engineer Online application will be activated from 1st June 2025 to 30th June 2025.

-> Candidates with a full-time engineering discipline in the relevant stream are eligible to apply.

-> The selection will be based on a Computer Based Test Group Task and/or Interview. Prepare for the exam using HPCL Engineer Previous Year Papers.

More Second Law of Thermodynamics and Entropy Questions

Get Free Access Now
Hot Links: teen patti vungo teen patti royal teen patti boss