Male Proxy Rule: Findings & Recommendations of the Panel - UPSC Editorials

Context: The panel formed by the Ministry of Panchayat Raj to examine the cases of female panchayat pradhans being represented by male members has submitted its report.

Download the Daily Current Affairs for UPSC Here!

Key Findings of the Ministry of Panchayat Raj Panel

Some of the key findings of the expert panel formed by the Ministry of Panchayat Raj are:

Women's Representation vs. Male Control

• Women occupy 46.6% of seats in Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) under policies of reservation.
• Yet, a large number of elected women pradhans do not wield actual power; their husbands, fathers, or brothers serve as proxies, referred to as "pradhan-patis."

How Male Dominance Undermines Women’s Leadership?

Male dominance tends to undermine women's leadership in these ways:

• Cultural Norms: There are norms that bind women into household activities, limiting their active participation in full measure.
• No Training: Most of them have received very little formal training or leadership experience, making them rely on the men in the family.
• Structural Barriers: Village power hierarchies continue to be dominated by men, discouraging women from taking decisions.
• Misuse of Reservation: Despite reservation policy, it has created proxy rule by male kin.

The fact that women are present in PRIs does not mean they are empowered unless they have the authority to make real decisions.

Read the article on Gender Issues in India!

Recommendations of the Panel to Curb Male Proxy Rule

A few of the major recommendations made by the panel for preventing male proxy rule in Panchayats are:

Legal and Administrative Reforms

• Tough Legislative Measures: To provide punishment to men who exercise authoritative power instead of elected women members.
• More Effective Accountability: Compelling pradhans to sign formal decisions, disallowing male family members from deciding on their behalf.
• Public Oath-Taking: Conducting public swearing-in ceremonies within gram sabhas in order to ensure the legitimacy of women pradhans.
• Women Ombudsmen: Inaugurating independent women officials to monitor panchayat rule and defend women leaders from coercion.

Empowering Women Leaders

• Leadership Training & Capacity Building: Sustaining capacity-building exercises regularly to assist women pradhans in understanding good governance, legislation, and administration.
• Support Infrastructure: Developing women panchayat leaders' federations for enabling knowledge transfer, mentoring, and collective bargaining among the federations.
• Financial Independence: Sustaining direct access of finance for women pradhans in order to bar male family members from having access to panchayat finances.
• Recognition & Rewards: Rewarding and publicly acknowledging women leaders who take an active role in governance and shatter male-dominated systems.

Not only voting for women, they must be provided with the tools and confidence to rule on their own.

Read the article on the Economic Empowerment of Women!

Concerns Over Exemplary Punishment for Male Proxies

Concerns expressed are regarding punishment of the male proxy. The list is as follows:

• Governance of fear: Punishment may deter women running for election out of fear or legal repercussions from the family.
• Social Backlash: Harsh punishment for male relatives might invite backlash from conservative societies and increase gender tensions.
• State Overreach: A top-down solution may not work in rural societies where cultural norms run deep.

Why Empowerment Works Better than Punishment?

Empowerment trumps punishment. Rather than punitive measures, systemic change, awareness, and training will have to be the focus, particularly leadership training.

• Capacity Building: Empowerment is a process that needs capacity-building to be reformed. Instead of punishing men, women are the ones we need to train and open up opportunities to leadership so that, in the long run, they can empower themselves.
• Community-Based: The change has to come from within the communities and not imposed through punitive legislation.
• Male Allies Matter: Instead of punishing men, involving them as allies in empowering women is a more sustainable model.

Read the article on the National Policy for Women 2016!

Final Thought: Reservation is only the beginning. Real empowerment begins the day women are able to lead without hindrance. India's democracy can be said to be complete only when elected women are not only symbolic representatives but actual decision-makers.

Hope all your questions about the topic have been answered by reading the editorial. Prepare well for UPSC IAS exams by downloading the Testbook App here!

UPSC Practice Question

Discuss the challenges in achieving true empowerment of women in Panchayati Raj Institutions despite the provision of reservation. How can a bottom-up approach aid in overcoming these challenges? (Ink in 150 words)